Fire: A way forward

Summary: 

The smoke inhalation from long-burning forest fires in northern California extracts a huge, frightening toll on residents’ respiratory health. We measure the ill effects and suggest potential remedies.

Impact Summary: 

The smoke inhalation from long-burning forest fires in northern California extracts a huge, frightening toll on residents’ respiratory health. We measure the ill effects and suggest potential remedies.

Results
Dylan Darling | April 19, 2009
  This year's fire season is about to rekindle long-running debates about how to prevent, suppress and recover from wildfire. Yet those debates have long been fought to a draw, and a Record Searchlight examination that began in the fall reveals the extent to which inaction continues to leave our lives, property and environment dangerously vulnerable. A series of stories set to run over the next several Sundays will seek to clearly define the debates, detail what is slowing potential progress and help illuminate a way forward. Summer 2008 brought a monumental fire season, costing 13 lives, smothering a recreational season in smoke and forcing widespread evacuations.
Results
Jocelyn Wiener and Ryan Sabalow | April 19, 2009
The smoke crept in during the final weeks of June. From the blazing forest, it reached its ashy brown fingers into Frank Walden's garden, choking his corn and poisoning his apple trees. It snuck under the doorway of his three-bedroom home on the edge of Big Bar. It entered his lungs. It refused to leave. Ten months after the lightning storms that triggered 136 wildfires in the Shasta-Trinity National Forest and clogged this region with smoke for an entire summer, Frank Walden doesn't feel much better. His resting heart rate recently clocked in at 141 beats per minute - twice as fast as normal, he says. He struggles to catch his breath.
Results
Jocelyn Wiener and Ryan Sabalow | April 19, 2009
Diagnosed with asthma for first time Deana Schmidt, 61, has lived in Lewiston since 1979. She bitterly remembers the chaos of the 1999 Lewiston Fire, a Bureau of Land Management-controlled burn that escaped containment and forced the evacuation of the town. But she says the ever-present haze last summer was far, far worse. While the 1999 fires caused worry and inconvenience, last summer’s fires made her sick. Schmidt said it started with coughing, then it progressed to wheezing and a respiratory infection. She was diagnosed with asthma for the first time in her life. She had to take weeks off work as a clerk at Lewiston’s only mini-mart. She needed an inhaler to breathe.
Results
Jocelyn Wiener | April 19, 2009
Last summer when the smoke rolled into the Hoopa Valley National Indian Reservation near Humboldt, members of the tribal leadership responded quickly. They evacuated their most vulnerable residents to the coast, and purchased special air filters to put in homes. They opened two public clean air facilities, installing air conditioners and air filters so people could have a place to escape the bad air. They established an emergency information hot line. They extended the hours at the community clinic. They got the county, the governor and the president to issue declarations of emergency, so that FEMA could help cover some of the quarter-million dollars these measures had cost.
Results
Record Searchlight staff | April 19, 2009
Minimize exposure The following tips are courtesy of the Shasta County Public Health Department: Stay indoors with windows and doors closed. Run air conditioner on "recirculate" setting. Do not run swamp coolers. Minimize or stop outdoor activities, especially exercise, during smoky conditions. Children are particularly vulnerable. People in a "high-risk" group or those who cannot find adequate shelter from the smoke outside may need to move temporarily to a place away from the smoke.
Results
Dylan Darling | April 26, 2009
Flames from last year's Moon Fire almost burned down Mike Boswell's home on Rector Creek Road near Ono. But ultimately the house was saved by brush thinning his family did on their 20 acres long before the blaze burned through in early July. "We are like the poster children for clearing your property," Boswell said. In the north state and around the West, the call for residents to clear vegetation around their homes has become the mantra of firefighting agencies.
Results
Dylan Darling | April 26, 2009
Thick underbrush and small trees in the north state's woods have the potential to pay for their own clearing. Although too small for milling, the trees and brush in the forest's lowest levels can serve as highly combustible fuel called biomass. Crews cut and chip the vegetation, which is then burned in a power plant to create electricity.
Results
Dylan Darling | April 26, 2009
  Clearing 1,700 miles of fuel breaks would be a massive task. But that's the goal of pilot projects created by the Quincy Library Group and supported by the U.S. Congress 11 years ago in an effort to prevent massive wildfires in eight Northern California counties, including Shasta and Tehama. But the once-promising plan has been stalled by lawsuits and timber sale permit appeals, group members say.
Results
Dylan Darling | April 26, 2009
A group of mountain bike riders gets ready to head off into the Weaverville Basin Trail system off Ridge Road. The area is part of the Weaverville Community Forest. (Andreas Fuhrmann/Record Searchlight) The best way to reduce fire danger in the woods close to a town is to put the community in control of forest management.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 3, 2009
Last summer Rayola Pratt experienced the fear that haunts so many in the north state. Wildfire tore through the woods near her home off Rock Creek Road west of Redding. "From here we could just watch the trees burst into flames," she said. When she evacuated as the Motion Fire pushed flames toward her place, she left her home in the care of a fire crew from Montana that slept on her deck between shifts. It was the biggest fire to burn near the home in the 40 years Pratt has lived there and she partially credits the firefighters for saving it.
Results
Ryan Sabalow | May 3, 2009
William Bradford had banked on the timber harvested from a stretch of private forest land his family has owned for the past 50 years as a nest egg. But the 67-year-old Junction City man watched last summer as firefighters armed with flame-dripping torches, flares and flammable liquid lit his land on fire, eventually scorching 70 of his 80 acres. Heat from the flames, which licked within feet of his home and crested the treetops, was so intense it boiled the sap in his trees, killing them.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 3, 2009
Larry Woodfill remembers when fighting the north state's fires was just about everybody's job. Woodfill's dad first put him on a fire line when he was 13, telling the other men his boy was 16. Back then, Woodfill recalls, fire agencies would take all the volunteers they could get. "In those days they would stop cars on the highway and pull people off and have them fight fire," said Woodfill, 72, who lives on South Fork Mountain with a view of Redding. "It worked well."
Results
Dylan Darling | May 3, 2009
The California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection is so focused on fire that in 2007, the agency switched its identifier, or official nickname, from CDF to Cal Fire. Meanwhile, the U.S. Forest Service sticks to its persona as land managers who happen to fight fire. "The Forest Service is not a fire department, it is a land management agency," said Arlen Cravens, fire management officer for the Shasta-Trinity National Forest.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 3, 2009
Where there's raging wildfire, there are often calls from the public for an air show - a sky full of air tankers and helicopters squelching the flames - state and fire officials say. "It's kind of a misconception of the public sometimes - that aircraft are going to be the panacea and save the day," said Dennis Brown, regional aviation safety manager for the U.S. Forest Service in California. But while firefighting aircraft usually are much more visible than the crews laboring below, they need ground support to extinguish fire.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 10, 2009
Catastrophic wildfire. It's a term that carries a heavy political load in the debates about how to manage a forest after fire has swept through. The more "catastrophic" the fire, the more extreme the work needed to mend the land and prevent future fire, some argue. Not only do the two primary players - timber interests and environmental groups - disagree about how to restore a forest after a fire, they also disagree about the very definition of catastrophic fire. They even disagree about whether the word should be used.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 10, 2009
The visual impact of a wildfire once the flames are gone can be just as dramatic as the blaze itself. Trees transformed into leaning snags. Brush left leafless and black. Still more trees toppled, turned to logs. While wildfire can drastically change the look of a forest, the debates over how to manage it afterward are just as heated as those that preceeded the flames. At issue is salvage logging, thinning and replanting.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 10, 2009
The U.S. Forest Service announced plans last November for a 155-acre salvage logging sale, saying the dead trees left on land torched by wildfires near Junction City and Big Bar could fuel future fire storms. But the Forest Service dumped those plans last month after an economic analysis of the sale and discussions with Trinity River Lumber Company in Weaverville, said Lance Koch, district ranger in Weaverville. He said steep terrain in the area would have meant logging the area with helicopters.
Results
Ryan Sabalow | May 10, 2009
Just because a fire burns through an area, it doesn't necessarily mean that another blaze won't come through a few years later and torch the land a second time. In fact, there are several recent examples in the north state. Sections of the 2001 Oregon Fire in Trinity County burned again five years later when the Junction Fire moved through. Areas in the Six Rivers National Forest burned by the Megram Fire in 1999 reignited June's lightning storms. Similarly, areas torched in 1987 around Hyampom lit up again last summer as the Lime Complex of fires.
Results
Redding Record Searchlight staff | May 18, 2009
Many environmentalists look back 200 years ago and yearn for the majestic forests that grew before the European settlement of California. Many in the timber industry look back 20 years and pine for the buzzing mills and the rough but respectable jobs that were the foundation of a thriving regional economy before the spotted owl wrecked it all. The past belongs in a museum. Teary nostalgia only obstructs the hard work that must be done immediately to address the rapidly growing threat of catastrophic wildfire.
Results
Dylan Darling | May 17, 2010
A year after wildfire killed 13 people and blackened hundreds of thousands of acres of forestland - costing nearly $170 million to fight - the north state's woods stand primed to burn again. The conflagration that ripped through the region last summer caused weeks of evacuations and disrupted thousands of lives. North state residents inhaled brown air for months, and many say they're still wheezing.
Results
Staff | October 25, 2010
 “Fire: A Way Forward,” published April 19, 2009, in the Redding Record Searchlight, examined the way the U.S. Forest Service battle forest fires, and concluded that new techniques could make an air quality difference for nearby communities.  After publication of the project, the forest service changed its policy priorities to include “human health.”
Results
Ryan Sabalow, Redding Record Searchlight | August 12, 2011
This story, which appeared in the Redding Record Searchlight on Aug. 11, 2011, updates a project produced by the newspaper and the CHCF Center for Health Reporting in April 2009.  In an effort to try to keep sooty air out of residents' lungs, local air quality managers will now have a direct role in determining how a fire will be fought if it erupts on federal land in California.